Saturdays 9 a.m. – 12 noon. Rain or shine. January 31, 2026 rummage sale has been canceled.
2026 Rummage Sale Dates: 1/17, 1/31 canceled, 3/14, 3/28, 4/4, 4/25, May 23 opening day for summer season.
RUMMAGE SHED CLOSED FOR DONATIONS FEBRUARY 2026
Please note: we DO NOT accept furniture, beds, bed frames, TVs, computers, mattresses of any kind, car seats, cribs.
Proceeds from the sales go to the ministry of the Montauk Community Church as well as the following organizations:
Montauk Food Pantry | The Retreat | Montauk Senior Center | Meals on Wheels | Big Brother/ Big Sister | St. Vincent de Paul | Toys for Tots | AMVETS | Cuban Sister Church
